Re: Spelljamming

[snip]
> I guess to some extent it probably is.  I use statements in various
> modules and other spells to help me make a determination.  I
> reiterate, however, magic jar clearly moves the mind with any life
> force

I don't see it as being so clear-cut. Remember, the caster gets to attack
with the creature's own THAC0, though there is a penalty. That would
indicate that not all of the "mind" is necessarily banished.

> so anything without a mind (even if only an ameobas instincts)
> needs to be looked at closely with respect to this spell at the least.
>  By definition a zombie/skeleton is completely mindless as is a golem
> (most golems anyway).

Oh, by the way, if first edition Reduce is as different as you say in
another post (only down to 1/10 size, rather than 1/10 inch) it probably
wouldn't be much help.

Hemlock