Search SJML Archives! (Powered by Google)

Previous Message: Re: Mecha
Next Message: Re: The Illithiad
Month Index: May, 1998


From:     "A Half-Drow Bard..." <tw692077@??????.???.???????.nl>
Date:     Wed, 6 May 1998 12:41:08 +0200 (METDST)
Subject:  Re: Lugribossk
> Well, the detail that irked me the most about it was that they assumed
> everyone would use the crappy psionics system from S&P - and the
> non-bug-fixed version too (where attacking hurts the attacker more than
> the defender). I think they should have provided CPHB stats for the new
> psionics, too.

Perhaps you may think that the psionics system from PO:S&P is is crappy,
but I think the "original" psionics system from CPHB is way too powerful.
How about taking that Disintegration power at level 4? It's possible in
the original system. I think that hurts.
But anyways, after having a psychometabolicist in the party - who almost
did nothing but heightened senses (a practice that lead to many, many
jokes) - my players were quite fed up with psionics. And I have to admit,
so am I. So I left the psionics to the monsters and occasional NPC
wild talents. Psionic monster remain cool, even though psionic PCs are not.
Come to that, I suspect you state the PO:S&P psi system is crappy,
because you think it makes the psis to weak. Then please let me horrify
you by stating that in my campaign I allow Magic Resistance to best
psionics. Serves them psychic little bastards just right.
Besides, what the heck is a psionicist anyways? According to the CPHB,
they're unrecognisable. In fact, they don't seem to have any place in
society at all as well. Now that's weird. "Gee, what do we have here? A
fighter, a paladin, a ranger, a wizard, a priest, a thief, and a bard.
Oh, and some non-descript, unrecognisable, not-readily-identifiable git
who really doesn't do anything at all when he's not adventuring. Well, I
guess he must be a psionicist." May I remind you of the fact that the CPHB
says that all classes can be recognized in some way - "you can identify a
wizard by the ink stains on his sleeves" - whilst claiming that a psionicist
cannot be recognized in any way? IMO, the psionicist class has absolutely no
place in a fantasy setting. The CPHB completely fails to give any way to fit
the psionicist into a fantasy society. Oh sure, they mention Uri Geller as
an example of psionicist. But I really wouldn't want my players to meet a
person like that in a fantasy campaign, because he certainly doesn't belong
in such a setting. And besides, Uri Geller was a fraud.
I don't want to insult any of you ppl that are so fond of psionicists, nor
am I saying you shouldn't use the "original" psi system. But if you are so
ensorcelled by them, I just want you to also see the other side of the coin.
I hope I didn't step on anyone's toes. Well, not too hard anyways. ;)

		- Half-Drow


Previous Message: Re: Mecha
Next Message: Re: The Illithiad
Month Index: May, 1998

SubjectFromDate (UTC)
Lugribossk    tlhawk@???-??.org    05 May 1998 02:19:53
Re: Lugribossk    Adam Miller    05 May 1998 02:47:38
Re: Lugribossk    The Mordu    05 May 1998 04:46:22
Re: Lugribossk    Staffan Johansson    05 May 1998 11:09:26
Re: Lugribossk    Leor Blumenthal    05 May 1998 17:07:49
Re: Lugribossk    Downer, Chris    05 May 1998 20:17:20
Re: Lugribossk    David Sarkies    06 May 1998 02:09:53
Re: Lugribossk    A Half-Drow Bard...    06 May 1998 10:41:08
Re: Lugribossk    daqueri    06 May 1998 13:36:31
Re: Lugribossk    The Astronauts' Guild    06 May 1998 14:10:07
Re: Lugribossk    A Half-Drow Bard...    06 May 1998 15:07:44
Re: Lugribossk    Shane Bryan    06 May 1998 22:36:45
Re: Lugribossk    Downer, Chris    06 May 1998 23:58:18
Re: Lugribossk    Manuel Gonzalez    08 May 1998 04:33:20
Re: Lugribossk    A Half-Drow Bard...    07 May 1998 08:49:44
Re: Lugribossk    A Half-Drow Bard...    07 May 1998 09:04:59
Re: Lugribossk    David Sarkies    07 May 1998 09:46:44
Re: Lugribossk    Downer, Chris    07 May 1998 23:42:40
Re: Lugribossk    The Astronauts' Guild    08 May 1998 09:18:01
Re: Lugribossk    A Half-Drow Bard...    08 May 1998 09:23:38
Re: Lugribossk    Wilson, M.D.    08 May 1998 12:03:22

[ SPJ-L@Cornell.edu ] [ Spelljammer@Leicester.ac.uk ] [ Spelljammer@MPGN.com ] [ Spelljammer-L@Oracle.Wizards.com ]