Search SJML Archives! (Powered by Google)

Previous Message: Re: Dwarven Hatchet [and some spells]
Next Message: Re: IEN Fascists?
Month Index: February, 1998


From:     gantr@???.edu
Date:     Sun, 01 Feb 1998 02:52:40 -0400 (EDT)
Subject:  Re: Moral Genocide? (Was: IEN Fascists?)
On Sat, 31 Jan 1998 Magistar2@???.com wrote:

>             True, true, genocide is an evil act.  However, that is genocide on
> people, goblins aren't people, they are monsters.  Also, what we perceive them
> as is one thing, but what they are is another.  We don't perceive goblins as
> evil, they are evil.

If we don't perceive goblins as evil, how do we know that they are evil?
We have to perceive their evil before we know that they are evil.  Since
we have to percieve them as evil in order for them to be evil, they can't
be evil.  After all "what we perceive them as is one thing, but what they
are is another".  Therefore they aren't evil.

Just kidding.  :)  (It's almost 3 AM here.  Can you tell.)

Okay, they aren't people.  Hypothetically.  Does this mean that I can
slaughter an entire species of anything that isn't people without it being
an evil act?  Here's a specific example:  wolves.  They aren't people.
They have no culture or civilization.  They live to kill and eat.
Everything else in their lives is secondary to that.  Can I exterminate
their entire species without it being an evil act?  Why or why not?  If
I can't, then what makes them different from goblins?

Rich Gant


Previous Message: Re: Dwarven Hatchet [and some spells]
Next Message: Re: IEN Fascists?
Month Index: February, 1998

SubjectFromDate (UTC)
Moral Genocide? (Was: IEN Fascists?)    gantr@???.edu    01 Feb 1998 06:52:40
Re: Moral Genocide? (Was: IEN Fascists?)    Wilson, M.D.    01 Feb 1998 14:59:27
Re: Moral Genocide? (Was: IEN Fascists?)    Voidwolf@???.com    01 Feb 1998 19:47:44
Re: Moral Genocide? (Was: IEN Fascists?)    Downer, Chris    02 Feb 1998 18:41:14
Re: Moral Genocide? (Was: IEN Fascists?)    Magistar2@???.com    03 Feb 1998 22:35:58
Re: Moral Genocide? (Was: IEN Fascists?)    Magistar2@???.com    03 Feb 1998 22:44:50
Re: Moral Genocide? (Was: IEN Fascists?)    gantr@???.edu    03 Feb 1998 22:35:58
Re: Moral Genocide? (Was: IEN Fascists?)    gantr@???.edu    03 Feb 1998 22:39:16
Re: Moral Genocide? (Was: IEN Fascists?)    Magistar2@???.com    06 Feb 1998 21:43:05
Re: Moral Genocide? (Was: IEN Fascists?)    Magistar2@???.com    06 Feb 1998 21:42:06

[ SPJ-L@Cornell.edu ] [ Spelljammer@Leicester.ac.uk ] [ Spelljammer@MPGN.com ] [ Spelljammer-L@Oracle.Wizards.com ]